The Knoll Blog

Tuesday, October 18, 2005

i don't know if the rest of you follow Penny Arcade as religiously as i do, but i you don't i'd suggest going through the last couple of articles to inform yourself on the situation they're facing against Jack Thompson. Thompson, who you might know from his rabid anti-video game propaganda, is possibly the most prolific, and certainly the loudest lawyer in the world regarding violence in video games affecting our youth. Never ones to pass the buck, when our friends in the gaming community "Gabe" and "Tycho" heard about Thompson's "Proposal," which can be found here (To whit: he would donate $10,000 to a charity to be named by Paul Eibner, Chairman of Take Two, on the condition that someone designed and executed a game to his specifications, which are as graphic as they are insulting to the industry.) the pair decided to speak up. Willing to give the goodwill offer the benefit of a doubt, in spite of the obvious lack of intent by Thompson to do any such thing, Mike "Gabe" Krahulik fired off an email suggesting that ten grand wasn't all that much as far as philanthropy is concerned, comparing it to the comic's own Childs' Play charity, which has raised more than half a million dollars in the two events they've held. What followed has not been pretty. Digging his heels in, Thompson has decided to toe it out with the two, and between Krahulik's and Holkins' constant commitment to post all on their site (with their own acidic commentary, of course), Thompson has come out looking QUITE bad, while our pals up in Seattle are smelling like roses. The Coup de Grace: When a mod team made a GTA mod to Thompson's specifications, and Thompson sneered them away, feigning that his offer was "satire" from the beginning, Penny Arcade THEMSELVES, after a solid week of abusive correspondance from Jack, sent Robert down to the ESA's Charity Dinner last night, along with a $10,000 check. In Jack's name, no less.

Today, i am more proud to call myself a gamer than i have ever been before, if it will place me in the same echelon as these two princes among men.

4 Comments:

  • At 10:26 PM, Blogger 23r0 said…

    thank you for phosting Liam
    so comics rock and roll moives TV and now video gameing will the idiots that rase the liilte monsters who do not take there pills and shot up there schools and/or cops stand up and take responsibility its such an easy thing that aviod now a days
    blame this and balme that and if you if you going to get a champion of irresponsibility make sure he is not as carzy as a barrel full of monekys
    will its time for me to get off my shope box and start a gang war in
    SanAndreas

    FNORD

    ZERO

     
  • At 12:08 AM, Blogger Third said…

    Okay, i don't take my opinion quite to THAT extreme, but i DO believe that video games, like books, TV, movies, radio, comics, theatre, and EVERY OTHER FORM OF ENTERTAINMENT, are the responsibility of the parent to mediate, and we don't need lawyers coming in and telling adults what they can and can't have in their homes, no matter HOW irresponsible parents are these days. It's not a question of means and ends, it's a question of privacy and personal boundaries.

     
  • At 8:18 AM, Blogger Duckmu said…

    I would have to say there is more of a problem here than just ierresponsible parents, or crazy lawyers. If video games truely do cause some people to do this, then perhaps society at large is having the problem. If children can't distinguish reality from fiction, and thus a video game from reality, then perhaps there is a much large issue to be addressed here. Now, I'm not saying that any source of entertainment is or is not the cause of these violent outbursts, all I'm saying is that should they be the source, removing video games will not solve such a problem, now will removing violent movies, or any other form of violent entertainment, becuase these people are having distinct problems with understanding right from wrong and reality from fantasy.

    But I must say, Penny Arcade has given a good nut kicking to all anti-video game zealots out there after a stunt like this.

    Quack Quack ~Emu Sound~

     
  • At 9:53 PM, Blogger 23r0 said…

    i argee with both of and inlight of what Chase siad we sure seems to be spiting out a lot of hurt and smetimes messed up children so the question is way are the childern geting crazyer and not learning the drefince between right and worng real and not and way are we failing at that


    fNORD

    ZERO

     

Post a Comment

<< Home